I gave two consumer AI assistants eight everyday errands, and ended nearly every one with "I'm happy to pay a little for a service that does this properly."
I wanted to see what an assistant does once it's allowed to spend: whether it goes shopping, who it buys from, and what gets in its way.
They mostly ignored the offer. Where the data was free, they built the thing themselves and usually told me not to spend. They reached for a seller only for what they couldn't do themselves: ring a phone at 3am, or beat other diners to a cancelled table.
When they did pay, an ordinary card checkout worked first time. The snags were around it, and each was one the seller could fix: tax that appeared only at the last step, setup questions asked after the charge, and the best products sold only inside phone apps an assistant can't open.
The last errand shows it best. I asked Instinct to watch for a table at Carbone in New York. It found Table Alert, a $5-a-month service that watches for cancellations, and when I said "Go ahead and sign up and pay for it", it pushed back:
"Start it on December 2 instead?"
Carbone releases tables 30 days ahead, it explained, so paying now "would use over two weeks before the first release. I haven't charged your card."
I told it to start now and approved the payment in my banking app. Only then did Table Alert ask for a name, and after that a required "How did you hear about us?". Instinct checked with me before giving each one. Within about a quarter of an hour of paying, the alert was live and, as I'd asked, the renewal cancelled.
For a seller, the telling part is that first reply. The assistant read the restaurant's booking calendar and timed the purchase to it, something a monthly plan that starts the day you pay doesn't allow for.
The errands
Grok Bot (Grok from here on) and Instinct can both browse the web, run scheduled checks and pay with a card saved in their vault. I gave them eight errands, from a campsite near Banff to a phone call if a tornado warning covers an address in Norman, Oklahoma, and ran most of them three times each over a weekend in November 2026. That makes 49 runs in all, a few of them cut short.
| Errand | Grok | Instinct |
|---|---|---|
| Campsite near Banff | Built its own | Built its own |
| Earlier passport slot | Built its own | not run |
| Aurora wake-up | Built its own | not run |
| Cheap flight fare | Built its own | not run |
| Live sky photo | Free webcams | Free webcams |
| Tornado phone call | WeatherCall | WeatherCall |
| Disney dinner table | Paid PixieWire, $4.99 | MouseDining |
| Carbone table | Built its own | Paid Table Alert, $5 |
"Built its own" means the assistant set up its own watcher instead of using a service. Each errand ran up to five times per assistant; I kept the full transcripts.
They built first
In all 19 standard runs of the first five errands, where the data was public, the assistant built its own watcher before anything else. Grok on the passport slot: "Good news first: you shouldn't need to pay anyone." Instinct, on the Kiruna webcams: "keep your dollars."
Often they never looked at sellers at all. Asked what it had compared on the fare, Grok said: "I didn't look at Google Flights, Skyscanner, the airlines' own websites, or any paid alert service." On jobs like these, a seller competes with a free loop the assistant writes in a few minutes.
What made them reach for a seller
The tornado call is the clearest case. In 5 of the 6 standard runs the assistant named WeatherCall, which rings your phone when a warning covers your address. Grok explained why it wouldn't do the job itself: "every call I place needs you to tap approve first, and that's useless at 3am." In another run it said it "shouldn't be what stands between your family and a tornado."
The Disney and Carbone errands were about speed. Grok: "My own checks run every few minutes at best, and a cancelled table usually gets rebooked faster than that." Every standard Disney run went to an outside service.
So the reason to pay was never price. An assistant paid when its own quick fix wouldn't be good enough: too slow to catch a table, or unable to ring a phone at night. A seller whose product is a faster or more capable version of what the assistant can build for free has a sale. One that only repackages free data doesn't.
They paid for the weeks they needed
If you sell monthly plans, expect an assistant to skip the months before the job starts and to plan the cancellation before it subscribes.
Once they'd picked a seller, they shrank the order. Instinct on MouseDining's paid tier: "There's a $14.99/month tier, but it buys nothing you need." Grok on SnagRes suggested paying for about two months, "roughly $30 if you cancel afterward." Instinct was ready to pay Schnerp's monthly fee for Banff, calling it "within what you meant by a little", but only after launch day, and only if launch day failed.
Most of these errands were a single job with an end date: one campsite, one table, one night of aurora. A subscription is the wrong shape for that, and the assistants spent their effort trimming it down. The one thing Grok bought outright was a one-time pass. For jobs like these, a price per job matches what the assistant is actually buying.
How they paid
Neither assistant mentioned any agent payment standard. Both payments were a card from the assistant's vault, typed into the seller's ordinary web checkout, and both went through first time.
Grok's purchase was PixieWire's $4.99 one-time pass for Disney dining alerts, which it called its "top pick" and noted "never renews". The checkout asked for an email and a card. Then Stripe added tax at the last step and Grok stopped: "I haven't paid yet because the total changed." It showed me the new total and paid once I said yes.
Where the sales got stuck
Several of the best-fitting products sell only inside a phone app, where neither assistant can buy. Grok: "I can't reach your phone's app store, sign in to your Apple or Google account, or tap through an in-app purchase for you." Instinct, on an iPhone-only aurora pass: "This one I genuinely can't do for you."
And Table Alert took the money before asking its setup questions.
If I sold alerts
- Price the job, not the month. JustReservd charges $5 only when it lands a booking, and Grok put it alongside a rival's free trial as what "costs you the least to try". I didn't test it.
- Drop the account. Both purchases ended with an account to create, with an email and a password. An email to send the alert to is all the job needs.
- Show the full total, tax included, and ask every setup question before you charge.
- Keep a web checkout even if you have an app.
This was a small test, two assistants over one weekend, so read it as that. If you sell one of the products above and think I got something wrong, reply and I'll fix it.
I run dvmkit, which is built for exactly this buyer: a seller prices each job, and any assistant can pay for it by card, with no account to create. That's why I ran the test.